2022 winners:
Fruit pie category:
1. “Strawberry Rhubarb Crumble” by Erin Tamm
2. “Pear Frangipane Tart” by Jaime McCormick
3. “Apple Gouda Pie” by Katy Lanzenby
Nut pie category:
1. “PPPPie (Pecan, Praline, Pumpkin Pie)” by Karen Duncan
2. “Pecan Old Fashioned” by Nate Shubin
3. “A pie” By Mary Beth Jourdan
Pumpkin/sweet potato pie category:
1. “S’more Pumpkin Please” by Arielle Hirschfield
2. “Ancona Garden-Variety Pie” by Christopher Weber
3. “Second Breakfast” by Katie Gruber
Creme pie category:
1. “LoLo’s CreLime Paradise Pie” by Lauren Pilot
2. “All in Whole Lemon Tart” by Chris Younkin-Wilson
3. “Mango Pie” by Susan Clapp
2021 winners:
Fruit pie category:
1. “Cherry Crumble” by Amanda Houser
2. “Criss Cross Mince” by Susan Carton
3. “Harvest Apple” by Brooke Lyon
Nut pie category:
1. “Post-It Note Pecan Pie” by Laura Pape
2. “Nutty Times!” by Julie Vassilatos
3. “More Brandy!” By Katie Maher-Lipinski
Pumpkin/sweet potato pie category:
1. “Pumpkin with Caramel Sauce” by Carol Ahrenholtz
2. “My Friend, Mr. Bunny”
3. “Orange with a Little Chocolate” by Joan Law
Creme pie category:
1. “Mom’s 80th Birthday Silk S’More Pie” by Jill White
2. “Dianthus” by Ruth Andrews
3. “Guinness Chocolate Cream Pie 2.0” by Yael Hoffman
2019 winners:
Fruit pie category:
1. “The Third One I Just Made” by Chris Andrews
2. “Sassy Pear Pie” by Nene Lozado
3. “Mac the Knife” by Susan Carton
Nut pie category:
1. “Nut-thing Compares to This” by Olivia McMeel
2. “Third Time’s a Charm?” by Lisa Samra
3. “Maple Bourbon Pie” by Alex Algie
Pumpkin/Sweet potato pie category:
1. “Bumpkin Pumpkin Pie” by Lea Redd
2. “PSL Pie” by Michelle Saulnier
3. “Ya Basic! Pumpkin” by Christina Salesberry
Creme pie category:
1. “Perfect Pitch Key Lime” by Amanda Houser
2. “Banana Fanna Fo Fanna” by Val Huston
3. “Dreamy Creamy Lemon Pie” by Laura Schulte-Cooper
2018 winners:
Fruit pie category:
1. “What a good boy am I pie” by Molly Herron
2. “Oglesby Avenue Raisin Apple Pie” by Kyle Coward
3. “Contains rhubarb and blueberries” by Chris Andrews
Nut pie category:
1. “Beyond nuts!” by Shirley Parada
2. “The nutty professor” by Maria Lozada
3. “Cho-Co-nut pie” by Carrie Hall
Pumpkin/Sweet potato pie category:
1. “Pie in the sky” by Katie Gruber
2. “The PunKing” by Harini Shah
3. “Pumpkin pie, pie, pie” by Shannon Younger
Creme pie category:
1. “The lime pie” by Ruth Andrews
2. “Bananas Foster Cream Pie” by Thomas Schmidt
3. “Citrus got real key lime pie” by Amanda Parada-Villatoro
2017 winners:
Fruit pie category:
1. “Failbetter Cranberry Pie” by Chris Andrews
2. “A PEARfect APPLEtunity” by Rachel McCauley
3. “Melba Lara” by Jessica Dunek
Nut pie category:
1. “Home Sweet Home Pecan Pie” by Susan Carton
2. “Black Bottom Pie, You Make the Rockin World Go Round” by Christina Salesberry
3. “Pre-Thanksgiving Day Pumpkin Pecan Pie” by Kyle Coward
Pumpkin/Sweet potato pie category:
1. “Slice, Slice Baby” by Lynette Bertsche
2. “Backdoor Sweet Potato Pie” by Leslie Travis
3. “Millie’s Perfect Pumpkin Pie” by Millie Norton
Creme pie category:
1. “Barking Up the Right Tree” by Kaylan Agarwal
2. “Dream Pie” by Natalie Grace
3. “It’s Peanut Butter Chocolate Time” Amanda Parada-Villatoro & Emilio Villatoro
2016 winners:
Fruit pie category:
1. “Pomme Pomme Pie” by Natalie Wright
2. “Blueberry 3.14” by David Mendoza & Lauren Solarski
3. “Peg’s Polka Dot Peach Pie” by Peggy Sanders
Nut pie category:
1. “Fancy Mixed Nuts Pie” by Kate Baldwin
2. “Bluegrass Pecan Pie” by Rex Haydon
3. “Peanut Pecan Pie” by Lisette Dunham & Joshua Schiffrin
Pumpkin/Sweet potato pie category:
1. “The Great Leslie” by Katie Maher-Lipinski
2. “Marigold Sweet Potato Pie” by Nene Lozado
3. “Sweet and Salty Pumpkin Pie” by Henry & Brooke Lyon
Creme pie category:
1. “#imwithher” by Lisa Samra
2. “Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse Pie” by Ruth Andrews
3. “Salted Caramel Awesomeness” by Margaret Richards
2015 winners:
Pumpkin/Sweet potato pie category:
1. “Pumpkin Praline Pie” by Maya-Camille Broussard
2. “Pumpkin Cheesecake Swirl” by Rebecca Luttrell
3. “Eleanor’s Birthday Pumpkin Pie” by Joan & Skylar Law
Creme pie category:
1. “Southside Key Lime Pie” by Dan Arnold
2. “B’s Dream Lemon Crème” by Peggy Sanders
3. “Hyde Park Sugar Cream” by Katie Maher-Lipinski
Fruit pie category:
1. “Freddy” by Lisa Samra
2. “Black and Blue” by Maya-Camille Broussard
3. “Cranberry Apple Pie with Almond Brittle” by Kate Baldwin
Nut pie category:
1. “Nut Job” by Kaylan Agarwal
2. “Yes Pe Can” by Evan Eschliman
3. “Not As Cute As Pushkin II” by Katie Maher-Lipinski
2014 winners:
Pumpkin/Sweet potato pie category:
1. “Sweet Potato Surprise” by Sheila Clay
2. “Piezometric” by Lisa Samra
3. “Felicia’s Candied Sweet Potato Pie” by Felicia Slayton-Young
Cream Pie category:
1. “Forget the Election Cashew Chocolate Cream Pie” by Kori Lusignan
2. “Salted Caramel Cloud” by Brigid Maniates
3. “Chocolate Peanut Butter Mousse Pie” by Rebecca Luttrell
Nut Pie category:
1. “Holiday Pecan Pie” by Deborah Weaver
2. “Not as Cute as Pushkin” by Katie Maher-Lipinski
3. “Salted Caramel Chocolate Pecan” by Jim Bloom
Fruit Pie category:
1. “Bluepepper Pie” by Molly Herron
2. “Smitten to the Core” by Lynette Bertsch
3. “New England Apple” by Mary Gehrke
2013 winners:
Fruit Pie category:
1. “Cherry Almond Pie” by Paul Mollica
2. “Scrumtrulescent Blueberry” by Katie Maher-Lipinski
3. “Autumn Rhubarb” by Peggy Sanders
Nut Pie category:
1. “Southern Pecan Pie” by Bette Sikes
2. “Ugle” by Ysobel Gallo
3. “Pecan Fudge Pie” by Rebecca Luttrell
Creme Pie category:
1. “Lemon Chess Pie” by Kate Baldwin
2. “A Turtle Named Chocolate” by Angeliki Vassilatos
3. “S’Cream Pie” by Deborah Weaver
Pumpkin/Sweet Potato category:
1. “Peter Peter” by Deborah Molaskey
2. “No Measure Sweet Potato Pie” by Lyletta Robinson
3. “Perfectly Pleasing Pumpkin Pie” by Shannan Younger
2012 winners:
Nut pie category:
1. “Eat This Pie” by Paige Reilly
2. “Nigel Von Nut” by Jake Agarwal
3. “DePaul’s DeLightful, DeLicious, and DeLovely” by Brian Barker, Skylar Garland, & Victoria Van Kirk Pride
Fruit pie category
1. “Affy Tapple Pie” by Molly Herron
2. “Apple Surprise” by Clair Smith
3. “Pretty Pie” by Page Reilly
Cream pie category
1. “Harriet” by Sharon Brinkman
2. “Yum!” by Andrew Howard
3. “Marvelous Mississippi Mud Pie” by Deborah & Nora Molasky
+ *honorable mention* – “Scrumtrulescent Dulce de Leche Banana Cream Pie” by Katie Maher-Lipinski
Pumpkin/Sweet potato pie category
1. “Autumn Falling Leaves” by Sofiya Kilbadze
2. “Cucurbita Curry in a Hurry” by Shawn Greene
3. “I Love You Day Sweet Potato Pie” by Sheila Clay